An unanswered message. A sentence you keep editing. A mistake that seems to say more about you than the work itself.
If perfectionism is familiar, an explanation can be appealing: perhaps you learned that getting things right was the safest way to be taken seriously. That may be worth exploring. It is also a hypothesis about your life, not something a research paper can establish from a distance.
Research has found associations between reported childhood invalidation and some forms of perfectionism. The useful question is what those findings actually let us say.
What does “invalidation” mean here?
In ordinary language, invalidation can mean having a feeling dismissed, minimised or treated as unacceptable. In research, the meaning is narrower: it depends on the questions participants answer and the measure a particular study uses.
That distinction matters. A difficult disagreement, a remembered pattern of dismissal and a questionnaire score are not interchangeable evidence. Nor does recognising yourself in a description establish a diagnosis.
Perfectionism also needs more than one word. Wanting to do something well is not identical to believing that other people demand perfection, or feeling compelled to hide every imperfection. Those differences are part of what researchers investigate.
What the studies found
Welch, Hyde Brott and Veilleux studied two undergraduate samples, with 255 and 277 participants. Their analyses examined reported parental invalidation and helicopter parenting alongside perfectionism and other psychological outcomes. Self-compassion was a prominent statistical mediator in their models. The paper appeared online in 2023 and in the journal’s 2025 volume.[1]
Here, “mediator” is a statistical term. It describes a proposed pathway in the data. These analyses do not establish that invalidation caused a person’s perfectionism, or that increasing self-compassion will reverse it. The study was not a trial testing that treatment claim.
A separate study by Chen, Hewitt and Flett examined childhood adversity in university students. It found associations with socially prescribed perfectionism—the sense that others require perfection—and with concealing imperfections. Adversity is a broader category than emotional invalidation; this paper cannot simply stand in for a direct test of invalidation.[2]
Curran and Hill’s meta-analyses examined parental expectations, parental criticism and perfectionism. Their findings connect reported parenting experiences with perfectionism, with particularly strong associations for socially prescribed perfectionism. They also examined changes in students’ reports over time.[3]
Taken together, these papers make relational experience a reasonable part of the conversation. They do not supply a single origin story for everyone who struggles with perfectionism.
Why association is not a personal explanation
Imagine two people who both revise an email ten times. One might fear a colleague’s criticism. Another might be learning a language. A third explanation might fit either of them better than the first two.
That is a hypothetical example, not a client story. Its point is modest: the same visible behaviour can invite different explanations. A group-level association cannot choose among them for an individual.
There are further limits. The studies discussed here rely substantially on participants’ reports, and the first two use student samples. Reports of childhood experience deserve attention, but these designs do not independently reconstruct a childhood or establish the direction of every relationship. Findings from undergraduates do not automatically describe all adults.
A useful reading of the evidence keeps those limits beside the result. It does not hide them in a footnote and then promise certainty in the headline.
Where self-compassion fits—and where certainty stops
It is tempting to turn a statistical result into instructions: “The problem is the belief, not the memory. Change the belief and the pattern disappears.” The studies above do not justify that promise.
Self-compassion is worth discussing because it appears in the research, not because these papers prove it is the single lever that will change your life. A proposed pathway and an effective intervention are different claims. The latter needs evidence from research designed to test change.
You do not have to turn this distinction into another task to perform perfectly. It simply leaves room for a more honest conversation: what might help, what you have already tried, what is still unclear, and what kind of support you want.
A few questions, without a verdict
If this topic feels familiar, you could begin with a present-day example rather than a complete theory of your childhood:
– When I say this must be perfect, what exactly am I asking it to be?
– Is there an actual requirement I can check, or am I trying to predict someone’s response?
– What would count as finished for this particular task?
– What kind of support would I want while I work out the answer?
These are optional reflection questions, not a tested treatment protocol. You do not need to answer them here, and they do not require you to decide who was right in every old disagreement.
Your feelings can deserve attention while your explanation remains open to revision. Research can give you language and questions. It cannot hand you a verdict about your family—or a guarantee about what will change next.
References
1. Welch K, Hyde Brott K, Veilleux JC. Hovering or invalidating? Examining nuances in the associations between controlling parents and problematic outcomes for college students. Journal of American College Health. 2025;73(1):204–216. Published online 2023. PubMed. DOI: 10.1080/07448481.2023.2209197.
2. Chen C, Hewitt PL, Flett GL. Adverse childhood experiences and multidimensional perfectionism in young adults. Personality and Individual Differences. 2019;146:53–57. DOI: 10.1016/j.paid.2019.03.042.
3. Curran T, Hill AP. Young people’s perceptions of their parents’ expectations and criticism are increasing over time: Implications for perfectionism. Psychological Bulletin. 2022;148(1–2):107–128. Author manuscript. DOI: 10.1037/bul0000347.
If you would like a conversation about what you are navigating, The First Hour is 60 minutes, one to one, online: €35 while I am certifying in Compassionate Inquiry; the rate rises when I qualify.
I am a PhD in medicinal chemistry, not in medicine. I do not diagnose or treat anything.